Sea level rise: A small California town embraces managed retreat

10 miles north of Monterey and a entire world away from Santa Cruz, Bruce Delgado gazed up a towering sand dune. Careful not to action on the beach front buckwheat that safeguards uncommon butterflies or the sea lettuce that survives only in secure habitats, he wound his way toward the ocean.

At the best, somewhat out of breath, he marveled at the sandy seaside that stretched for miles alongside the bay. Massive surf broke into rhythmic cusps by the shore. A red-tailed hawk soared above his town of Marina, where by even with its title, no dock or pier exists to interrupt this perspective.

Not significantly of the California coast feels like this any longer, with no pavement or harbors or parking heaps ideal up to substantial tide. Dwelling to sharks and coyotes, shorebirds and butterflies, this little city not much from Silicon Valley is a reminder that the beach itself used to be wild.

“It’s the best-held key. Living in Marina is a preference,” explained Delgado, a botanist turned mayor who has managed to pull off what several towns have not. “Sometimes when you go jogging on the beach, you see vultures consuming lifeless sea lions. … There’s a large amount of nature taking place in these dunes.”

At a time when Del Mar, Pacifica and other coastal metropolitan areas are preventing to protect their homes and roads from the soaring sea, Marina has embarked on a route less traveled. In this article in this Army turned university city, residents are finding out how to adjust with the ocean as the drinking water moves inland.

Sea partitions are forbidden, and sand replenishment projects seem to be unnatural in a city so happy of its indigenous environment. Officials as a substitute are embracing tips that have been political suicide in other places: Demand genuine estate disclosures for sea degree increase, go infrastructure absent from the h2o, perform with the personal vacation resort in town to relocate its oceanfront . Scienroperty — a plan known as managed retreat.

This smaller but energetic town of 23,000 states it is fought plenty of coastal challenges around the decades to know that terrible concepts ought to be stopped faster than later. A controversial sand mine on the seashore is last but not least shutting down immediately after a century of dredging away the coastline. Citizens are nonetheless combating a large water firm making an attempt to build a desalination plant.

Bruce Delgado, the mayor of Marina, appears to be out at the sandy beach that stretches for miles.

(Rosanna Xia / Los Angeles Periods)

With sea stage rise, the mere recommendation of producing area for the ocean and turning primary genuine estate into open area has upended other towns up and down the coast — at least one mayor has been ousted. But Marina is distinct, a metropolis report declared, and as a substitute will demonstrate the state and nation how to adapt to a altering planet.

“Marina is this sort of a fantastic take a look at circumstance,” explained David Revell, a coastal geomorphologist who has encouraged many cities, including Marina, on sea level increase. “Here we have the precedent of a group who understands that … there has to be more than enough guide time to get items out of the way — in advance of it’s in the way.

“That is a seriously potent information to the rest of California.”


Accepting the energy of the ocean has very long been element of Marina’s heritage. For a long time, the area was outlined by Ft. Ord, a sprawling Army base that at the time was home to as quite a few as 50,000 troops. Soldiers coveted assignments in this article, but large waves, rip currents and unstable cliffs made the beach far too harmful to take pleasure in.

By 1994, the Army had packed up and remaining — the largest armed service base closure in the United States at the time. A sign nowadays, wherever a making as soon as stood, describes “a coastal assault the Army could not end.”

“Soldiers after guarded this shoreline against sea-borne attack, but one particular force proved too potent to halt. Coastal erosion, the wearing absent of these bluffs and beaches by ocean waves, has been steadily going the shoreline inland,” according to the indicator, which stated that the bluffs at Ft. Ord erode landward 5 to 8 ft a 12 months.

Component of the land was turned into a new university, Cal State Monterey Bay one more swath was remodeled into Ft. Ord National Monument. California Condition Parks cleaned up the coastal extend — about 4 miles of seaside — and programs to construct new campgrounds for the general public.

The city of Seaside owns a portion, and Marina is continue to figuring out how to produce far more than 1,000 acres on the inland facet of Highway 1 (the internet site contamination and labor prices have not been the least complicated sell to builders).

Delgado, a botanist for the Bureau of Land Administration, moved below in 1996 to perform on the restoration. He obtained swept into nearby politics in 1999, when he listened to that metropolis leaders needed to convert open up house into 3,500 huge properties, positioning Marina as a bedroom local community for a new corporate small business park more than the hill.

He went doorway to doorway with neighbors and acquired Marina to build an “urban development boundary” north of town for at minimum 20 several years.

Marina Dunes

Citizens of Marina say they worth their sandy shorelines and dunes, urging officials to defend them from coastal erosion and sea amount rise.

(Robert Gauthier / Los Angeles Occasions)

Marina Dunes

Invasive, nonnative ice plant grows alongside native species in Marina’s towering sand dunes.

(Robert Gauthier / Los Angeles Periods)

Much of the shoreline stays undeveloped — generating selections today a lot a lot less challenging when it will come to scheduling for sea degree rise. The town points builders as a substitute to parcels downtown and farther inland. A new planned group, Sea Haven, is now advertising and marketing the rewards of “homes around the sea.”

Delgado grew up in Southern California likely to Laguna Beach and Dana Position and has viewed individuals sleepy beach front cities greenlight multimillion-greenback residences and change their shorelines into tourist destinations.

Marina could undoubtedly use some of that tax earnings (it just received ample money for a new firetruck), but Delgado does not envy other mayors who now have to grapple with the politics of telling their wealthiest citizens what to do with their oceanfront houses.

“With sea level rise, as with enhancement, cities like Marina are using it seriously and logically,” he reported. “We’re not going to lament that our predecessors didn’t just take this seriously. We’re not likely to wait until finally emergencies come about to choose motion.”


Marina’s coastline has one particular of the greatest prices of erosion in California — exacerbated by a Mexico-based corporation, Cemex, that for decades experienced been trucking absent sand unchecked. Researchers estimate the mine by itself has eroded an typical of 4 feet of coast each and every 12 months.

Significant silica information in this region helps make the sand beneficial for sandblasting, filtration and area ending. Other operations together Monterey Bay have shut down above the a long time, but Marina proceeds to view in horror the huge gap in its beach front, where by machines roar all working day as they suck absent sand.

Dredging vessel in Marina Dunes

A dredging vessel on the beach front in Marina, wherever a sand mine has operated for many years.

(Robert Gauthier / Los Angeles Times)

Idle dredging equipment from the Cemex sand processing plant in Marina Dunes

Idle dredging devices from the Cemex sand-processing operation in Marina.

(Robert Gauthier / Los Angeles Instances)

Stopping this mine would dramatically slow down the impacts of sea amount rise — giving anyone additional time to adapt, mentioned Layne Lengthy, the metropolis supervisor. Marina’s dunes, even at 100 toes tall, are significantly shrinking from a net decline of sand each individual calendar year.

Right after years of controversy, Cemex will phase out functions by the conclude of this year. The company has a few decades to go out and provide the land to a nonprofit or federal government agency that would maintain the home in perpetuity and supply community access.

Residents are now preventing California American Water’s proposal to use part of this internet site for a desalination task. The water wouldn’t even serve Marina, they mentioned, and making new infrastructure on an eroding coastline just does not seem like intelligent arranging.

Very long, on a current wander to the mine, shook his head at the odor of machinery on the beach front and the smokestacks in the length. He envisions a restored coastline with character trails and overlooks, probably even indications instructing site visitors about sea amount rise.

Marina has prolonged recognized the consequences of coastal erosion, as opposed to other towns that are just starting to discussion the trade-offs. As more than 35 coastal cities and counties in California agonize about the tough fees and choices, Marina stands out as a group enthusiastic about deciding upon managed retreat.

Many years of preventing corporate interests, Prolonged explained, has unified the city on how to system for sea level increase.

“We have a shot to do it ideal.… Due to the fact of the way we produced, and did not produce, we have the potential to have a quite great managed retreat approach,” he stated. “Adopting this program will assure for our potential generations that our coastline is heading to stay this way.”


The city’s sea stage increase program, now in its last levels, has acquired small resistance. In a city wherever one particular-third of the group is small cash flow and far more than 60% are not white, sustaining a shoreline that can be savored by all is best precedence. In meetings and surveys, residents urged metropolis leaders to shield their shorelines if stress from personal property owners or company passions will take maintain.

At a the latest community workshop, officials reaffirmed their motivation to banning sea walls and have been cautious of any strategies that sounded unnatural. They talked about their vision to protect the town from “the damaging impacts of urban sprawl” whilst still developing economically as “a attractive residential and small business local community in a normal setting.”

The system lays out a framework in excess of the following couple many years for when place of work buildings, a sewer pump and an aging h2o remedy facility really should contemplate relocating absent from the sea. Beach facilities, these as a parking good deal and community restrooms, might also will need to relocate.


David Revell, a coastal geomorphologist who has consulted for a quantity of metropolitan areas, which include Marina, admires the coastline at Marina State Seaside.

(Robert Gauthier / Los Angeles Moments)

Triggers will be discovered on when these conclusions must be produced, primarily based on how substantially time it requires to permit new development. When the sea rises to a sure threshold or erosion gets in just a selected length, for case in point, park officials should begin strategies to move the parking ton — alternatively than just cornering off sections when they collapse.

As for non-public house, town planners broached the Sanctuary Beach Resort about checking in every single renovation cycle, about five to 7 yrs, to contemplate when may well be a great time to transfer nine oceanfront properties with no sacrificing the overall number of rooms — probably by turning some of the resort’s one-tale cottages into two-tale lodging farther inland.

Jeroen Gerrese, the resort‘s general manager and chair of the Monterey County Hospitality Assn., mentioned he is open up to even more discussions on how to accommodate the ecosystem and preserve what makes the resort particular.

Unlike other resorts along the peninsula, which are closer to attractions these as the Pebble Seashore golf system and the Monterey wharf, his is the only a person that can supply beach walks and sunset bonfires and direct accessibility to the sand.

“Everyone else can appear at the ocean,” Gerrese stated, “but they simply cannot get there from their vacation resort.”

Walking alongside an unpaved path, he pointed to the bocce ball court docket made from recycled oyster shells, the pastel-colored bikes made available to friends, the restricted use of plastic. Born in the Netherlands beneath sea amount, Gerrese says he respects the water a good deal. Now a resident of Marina, he jumps at opportunities to recruit from the local college and vegetation trees all around city.

Using care of the environment is component of the business enterprise approach and a shared duty, he reported, stooping down to choose up a rogue sweet wrapper. “If you do not consider about doing work with nature, you’re not true to you as a business owner and not real to your local community that you reside in.”

He seems up and admires the surf crashing on to shore. There’s no issue battling, he stated, a force as highly effective as the ocean.

Resource connection